10 models to compare

Which puck screen uses less headspace at the right diameter?

Normcore’s screen is 58.5 mm across and 1.7 mm thick; MHW-3BOMBER’s is 58.5 mm across and 0.8 mm thick. Thickness separates them.

A size limit cannot certify fit or calculate a safe coffee dose.

Disclosure: Havenraft participates in the Amazon Associates Program and may earn commissions from qualifying purchases through product links on this site.

With no preferences selected: Puck Screen (53.4 mm) is one option to compare.

No hands-on testingMethod and sources

Puck Screen (53.4 mm) · first with a product link

Model / item: PUC-SCR-534

Screen diameter: 53.4 mm.
Steel grade: 316L stainless steel.

What to note:

Thickness: 1.7 mm.

View at Crema Coffee Products

If you choose Up to 51 mm for screen diameter, the first option with a product link becomes V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm).

10 models compared; 10 have a product-page link.

The picks

5 options to compare

Compare the details that matter to your setup.

An option to compare

Puck Screen (53.4 mm)

Screen diameter: 53.4 mm.

Model / item: PUC-SCR-534

Key details

Steel grade: 316L stainless steel.

What to note

Thickness: 1.7 mm.

Compare specs: Screen diameter: 53.4 mm here; 51 mm on V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm).

Screen diameter: 53.4 mmThickness: 1.7 mmSteel grade: 316L stainless steel

See all 3 specs

Screen diameter53.4 mm

Thickness1.7 mm

Steel grade316L stainless steel

3 of 3 specs available · source checked September 26, 2026 · Source ↗
Crema Coffee Products · Product page checked September 26, 2026

View at Crema Coffee Products Compare

Screen diameter: Up to 51 mm

V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm)

Steel grade: 316 stainless steel.

Model / item: SjpV1LhYin51

Key details

Screen diameter: 51 mm.

What to note

Not listed by the maker: thickness.

Compare specs: Steel grade: 316 stainless steel here; 304 stainless steel on V2 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.8 mm thick).

Screen diameter: 51 mmSteel grade: 316 stainless steel

See all 3 specs

Screen diameter51 mm

Steel grade316 stainless steel

ThicknessNot listed by the maker

2 of 3 specs available · source checked September 26, 2026 · Source ↗
IKAPE · Product page checked September 26, 2026

View at IKAPE Compare

Thickness: Up to 0.2 mm

V4 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.2 mm thick, silver)

Thickness: 0.2 mm.

Model / item: SjpV4Yin51

Key details

Screen diameter: 51 mm.

What to note

Steel grade: 304 stainless steel.

Compare specs: Thickness: 0.2 mm here; 1.7 mm on Puck Screen (53.4 mm).

Screen diameter: 51 mmThickness: 0.2 mmSteel grade: 304 stainless steel

See all 3 specs

Screen diameter51 mm

Thickness0.2 mm

Steel grade304 stainless steel

3 of 3 specs available · source checked September 26, 2026 · Source ↗
IKAPE · Product page checked September 26, 2026

View at IKAPE Compare

Steel grade: 304 stainless steel

Flair 58 Puck Screen

Screen diameter: 58.5 mm.

Model / item: 35210318N

Key details

Steel grade: 304 stainless steel.

What to note

Not listed by the maker: thickness.

Compare specs: Screen diameter: 58.5 mm here; 53.4 mm on Puck Screen (53.4 mm).

Screen diameter: 58.5 mmSteel grade: 304 stainless steel

See all 3 specs

Screen diameter58.5 mm

Steel grade304 stainless steel

ThicknessNot listed by the maker

2 of 3 specs available · source checked September 26, 2026 · Source ↗
Flair Espresso · Product page checked September 26, 2026

View at Flair Espresso Compare

Also compare 5

V2 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.8 mm thick)

Thickness: 0.8 mm.

Model / item: SjpV2Yin51

Key details

Screen diameter: 51 mm.

What to note

Steel grade: 304 stainless steel.

Compare specs: Thickness: 0.8 mm here; 0.2 mm on V4 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.2 mm thick, silver).

Screen diameter: 51 mmThickness: 0.8 mmSteel grade: 304 stainless steel

See all 3 specs

Screen diameter51 mm

Thickness0.8 mm

Steel grade304 stainless steel

3 of 3 specs available · source checked September 26, 2026 · Source ↗
IKAPE · Product page checked September 26, 2026

View at IKAPE Compare

Comparing Puck Screen (53.4 mm) · V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm)

Compare

Save this comparison

Already have a model in mind?

Compare

The facts that differ

Choose up to three models to compare side by side.

Differences only

0 identical specs shown. Details that do not apply to these models are omitted.

Published specification comparison
Spec	Puck Screen (53.4 mm)Model / item: PUC-SCR-534No preferences selected.	V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm)Model / item: SjpV1LhYin51No preferences selected.
Screen diameter	53.4 mm	51 mm
Thickness	1.7 mm	Not listed by the maker
Steel grade	316L stainless steel	316 stainless steel

Puck Screen (53.4 mm)

Model / item: PUC-SCR-534

No preferences selected.

Screen diameter: 53.4 mm
Thickness: 1.7 mm
Steel grade: 316L stainless steel

V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm)

Model / item: SjpV1LhYin51

No preferences selected.

Screen diameter: 51 mm
Thickness: Not listed by the maker
Steel grade: 316 stainless steel

Puck Screen (53.4 mm)

View at Crema Coffee Products

V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm)

View at IKAPE

Compare all 10 models

— = no verified listing yet. The published order is independent of links.

All models and their decision specs
Product	How it compares	Key spec	Compare	Action
Puck Screen (53.4 mm)	Compared with V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm): screen diameter, 53.4 mm vs 51 mm. Model / item: PUC-SCR-534	Screen diameter: 53.4 mm	Compare	View at Crema Coffee Products
Flair 58 Puck Screen	Compared with Puck Screen (53.4 mm): screen diameter, 58.5 mm vs 53.4 mm. Model / item: 35210318N	Screen diameter: 58.5 mm	Compare	View at Flair Espresso
V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm)	Compared with V2 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.8 mm thick): steel grade, 316 stainless steel vs 304 stainless steel. Model / item: SjpV1LhYin51	Screen diameter: 51 mm	Compare	View at IKAPE
V2 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.8 mm thick)	Compared with V4 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.2 mm thick, silver): thickness, 0.8 mm vs 0.2 mm. Model / item: SjpV2Yin51	Screen diameter: 51 mm	Compare	View at IKAPE
V3 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.8 mm thick)	Compared with V4 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.2 mm thick, silver): thickness, 0.8 mm vs 0.2 mm. Model / item: SjpV3Yin51	Screen diameter: 51 mm	Compare	View at IKAPE
V4 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.2 mm thick, silver)	Thickness: 0.2 mm; Screen diameter: 51 mm. Model / item: SjpV4Yin51	Screen diameter: 51 mm	Compare	View at IKAPE
Espresso Puck Screen (58.5 mm, 0.8 mm thick)	Compared with Puck Screen (53.4 mm): screen diameter, 58.5 mm vs 53.4 mm. Model / item: FG5590	Screen diameter: 58.5 mm	Compare	View at MHW-3BOMBER
Espresso Puck Screen (58.5 mm, 316 steel, silver)	Compared with Puck Screen (53.4 mm): screen diameter, 58.5 mm vs 53.4 mm. Model / item: NC10063	Screen diameter: 58.5 mm	Compare	View at Normcore
Puck Savers (58 mm, pack of 2)	Compared with Puck Screen (53.4 mm): screen diameter, 58 mm vs 53.4 mm. Model / item: PSV-2	Screen diameter: 58 mm	Compare	View at Weber Workshops
Puck Screen (58 mm, pack of 1)	Compared with V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm): screen diameter, 58 mm vs 51 mm. Model / item: PS-1	Screen diameter: 58 mm	Compare	View at Weber Workshops

Puck Screen (53.4 mm)

Compared with V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm): screen diameter, 53.4 mm vs 51 mm.

Model / item: PUC-SCR-534

Screen diameter: 53.4 mm

CompareView at Crema Coffee Products

Flair 58 Puck Screen

Compared with Puck Screen (53.4 mm): screen diameter, 58.5 mm vs 53.4 mm.

Model / item: 35210318N

Screen diameter: 58.5 mm

CompareView at Flair Espresso

V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm)

Compared with V2 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.8 mm thick): steel grade, 316 stainless steel vs 304 stainless steel.

Model / item: SjpV1LhYin51

Screen diameter: 51 mm

CompareView at IKAPE

V2 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.8 mm thick)

Compared with V4 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.2 mm thick, silver): thickness, 0.8 mm vs 0.2 mm.

Model / item: SjpV2Yin51

Screen diameter: 51 mm

CompareView at IKAPE

V3 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.8 mm thick)

Compared with V4 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.2 mm thick, silver): thickness, 0.8 mm vs 0.2 mm.

Model / item: SjpV3Yin51

Screen diameter: 51 mm

CompareView at IKAPE

V4 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.2 mm thick, silver)

Thickness: 0.2 mm; Screen diameter: 51 mm.

Model / item: SjpV4Yin51

Screen diameter: 51 mm

CompareView at IKAPE

Espresso Puck Screen (58.5 mm, 0.8 mm thick)

Compared with Puck Screen (53.4 mm): screen diameter, 58.5 mm vs 53.4 mm.

Model / item: FG5590

Screen diameter: 58.5 mm

CompareView at MHW-3BOMBER

10 catalog models

How the comparison works

Your choices are compared with each model’s product details. A missing or conflicting value stays unknown and cannot satisfy a choice you select. The starting order helps you browse; it does not rate real-world performance.

Source dates appear with each link below. A source date does not confirm today's price or stock.

Finder methodology Report a correction

Sources for all 10 models

Espresso Puck Screen (58.5 mm, 0.8 mm thick): Source 1 ↗ · September 26, 2026
Espresso Puck Screen (58.5 mm, 316 steel, silver): Source 1 ↗ · September 26, 2026
Flair 58 Puck Screen: Source 1 ↗ · September 26, 2026
Puck Savers (58 mm, pack of 2): Source 1 ↗ · September 26, 2026
Puck Screen (53.4 mm): Source 1 ↗ · September 26, 2026
Puck Screen (58 mm, pack of 1): Source 1 ↗ · September 26, 2026
V1 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm): Source 1 ↗ · September 26, 2026
V2 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.8 mm thick): Source 1 ↗ · September 26, 2026
V3 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.8 mm thick): Source 1 ↗ · September 26, 2026
V4 Espresso Puck Screen (51 mm, 0.2 mm thick, silver): Source 1 ↗ · September 26, 2026

A thin screen saves space above the dose

Weber Workshops uses a 58 mm diameter for its screen designs, with 0.19 mm thickness for the thinner design and 2 mm for the thicker design. Normcore’s 58.5 mm screen is 1.7 mm thick. Treat thickness as occupied headspace before choosing a dose, not as a prediction of espresso quality.

Diameter is a maximum-limit filter, so it admits smaller screens too. It does not certify basket compatibility. Use your basket’s fit guidance and equipment headspace instructions for the exact screen and dose.

Steel descriptions leave extraction unanswered

Crema Coffee Products uses 316L stainless steel for its 53.4 mm screen, while Normcore names 316 stainless steel. Those grade labels distinguish materials, leaving extraction and taste unevaluated here.

Thickness is missing for 2 screens, including Flair Espresso’s option. Missing thickness cannot pass an active thickness limit. Pack quantity and diameter variants also need checking on the exact offer; neither changes the need for clearance above the coffee.

Before you buy

Why do Flair and IKAPE V1 have no thickness?

The saved material does not verify those thicknesses. They stay visible without a thickness preference, but cannot satisfy an active limit for that field.

Does a small diameter establish basket compatibility?

A maximum diameter admits smaller screens too. Use your basket maker’s fit guidance and equipment headspace instructions; a screen occupies space above the coffee. Both screens are 58.5 mm across: Normcore is 1.7 mm thick and MHW-3BOMBER is 0.8 mm thick. Thickness separates them. MHW-3BOMBER is worth comparing if your basket accepts that diameter and you want less screen thickness. A size limit cannot certify fit or calculate a safe coffee dose.

Does steel grade establish extraction quality?

Weber Puck Savers use 316L stainless steel, while its Puck Screen names 316 stainless steel. Those descriptions cannot establish extraction performance. Pack quantities and size options are counted as one design.